If you click a link on this page, then go on to make a purchase, we may receive a commission but at no extra cost to you. Learn More

Best Coffee Creamer Brands In 2024 – Healthy Coffee Creamer Reviewed

Every day, half of the adults in the United States drink a cup of coffee!

Whether it’s purely for the taste or the caffeine, people can be pretty specific about how they want their coffee to taste. Some like it black, but most enjoy putting some creamer in their cup of joe.

It can be powdered or in liquid form, and most are dairy-free. Adding creamer to your coffee might be a good option for you if you prefer your coffee to be a bit sweeter.

In this article, we’ll discuss commonly asked questions about coffee creamer and will take a look at the top five creamers of today.

best creamer for coffee

Top five creamers

Coffee-Mate The Original Powder Coffee Creamer
  • Overall best coffee creamer.
  • Tastes amazing in coffee.
  • Affordable option.
Micro Ingredients Organic Coconut Milk Powder
  • Beautiful coconut taste.
  • Organic
  • Free of soy and gluten.
  • Six month shelf life.
Picnik Keto Creamer
  • Low Carb coffee creamer.
  • Great creamer to fuel your body.
  • Free of artificial flavoring, sugar & carb free.
International Delight Coffee Creamer Singles
  • Sweet & Rich Flavor.
  • No Gluten or lactose.
  • Great liquid creamer.
Califia Farms Unsweetened Oat Milk Barista Blend
  • Great flavor.
  • Free of any dairy, soy or gluten.
  • Cheap Option

Now that you’ve got a clue about what you’re looking for in coffee creamer let’s go over some of the highest-rated coffee creamers that are available on Amazon.

We’ll start with some quick facts (price, ingredients, flavors, etc.) and then will dive a little deeper into whether or not the creamer is right for you!

1. Overall Best Coffee Creamer – Coffee-Mate The Original Powder Coffee Creamer

This powdered creamer from Nestle is a fan-favorite, having been given almost ten-thousand five-star reviews on Amazon.

This formula is offered in other flavors as well, but the classic seems to be the most popular.

With a taste that is similar to traditional milk or cream, this creamer is a great alternative for people who love the taste of dairy products but are too lactose sensitive.

An added benefit is that this creamer is in powder form, which means that it has a longer shelf life and doesn’t need to be kept in a fridge.

As far as nutrition goes, this creamer has 20 calories and one gram of added sugar per serving.

This creamer does have more processed ingredients, so if you’re looking for a fresher option, this might not be the creamer for you! If you are looking for the best coffee creamer flavor of the best cream for coffee, this is the best coffee creamer for you!

2. Sugar Free Coffee Creamer – Micro Ingredients Organic Coconut Milk Powder

If you like the taste of coconut milk, this might be the perfect creamer for you!

The organic coconut milk powder from Micro Ingredients is a powder that dissolves easily into smoothies and coffee while providing the same taste and texture as real coconut milk.

This powder is also free of soy and gluten, making it a great option for those who have a sensitivity to those.

Once opened, the coconut milk powder will have a shelf life of about six months.

Though this formula has no added sugars, it does carry 41 calories and 3 grams of fat with each serving.

This is a great option for someone who is looking for the specific flavor and texture of a coconut milk creamer. If you were looking for a sugar free creamer, or the healthiest coffee creamer, you have found the right coffee creamer for you!

3. Low Calorie Coffee Creamer – Picnik Keto Creamer

If you’re on the hunt for a coffee creamer that is low in carbs, look no further1 Picniks keto creamer is made out of three main ingredients whey protein, MCT oil, and grass-fed butter.

These ingredients are meant to fuel your body and make you feel fuller for longer MCT oil is easier for your body to digest and is converted into energy instead of being stored as fat.

Picnik’s creamer manages to taste just like half and a half while also being free of artificial flavoring, sugar, and carbs free it is a liquid the keto creamer needs to be stored in a fridge after being opened. It will stay good for about 14 days, but many customers say that they finish the container well before that!

A serving size is one-fourth of a cup and contains 50 calories as well as 4.5 grams of fat.

This creamer is ideal for anyone that is trying to stick to a low-carb diet! However, it does contain milk, so if you are looking for non-dairy creamer, you’ll have to pass on this one!

The brand also has other formulations that do not contain dairy that you might want to take a look at. If you were looking for a fat free sugar free coffee creamer or just a healthy creamer, this is the right coffee creamer for you!

4. Best Tasting Coffee Creamer – International Delight Coffee Creamer Singles

These creamer singles are the perfect option if you are looking for a more decadent creamer to put into your coffee. Sweet and rich, this creamer was inspired by the taste and feel of the sweet cream ice cream flavor from Coldstone.

A bonus is that this creamer is void of any gluten or lactose, making this a great option for those looking for a non-dairy or gluten-free creamer.

These perfectly packaged singles are perfect for grab-and-go situations, with each container holding 12 grams of creamer.

Due to the type of packaging, these singles can either be kept in the fridge or the pantry. Regular customers recommend putting the cups in the fridge since the cooler temperature will help cool down any cup of coffee that is too hot!

When it comes to nutrition, this creamer is unhealthier than most. The first two ingredients listed are cane sugar and palm oil.

Both of which are bad for your health Palm oil is high in saturated fats and can negatively affect your health if consumed in large amounts.

Each single is one serving and contains 30 calories. 1.5 grams of fat and five grams of carbs. If you’re looking for a healthy creamer for your coffee, then this one is not for you!

If you are looking for the best creamer for coffee or the best liquid creamer, this is the a good coffee creamer for you!

5. Best Coffee Creamer For Weight Loss – Califia Farms Unsweetened Oat Milk Barista Blend

This creamer is perfect for those with allergies as it is free of any dairy, soy, gluten, or nuts!

Mimicking the flavor and thickness of dairy, this blend tastes just like milk and is perfect for those who are lactose-intolerant. If paired with a steamer, this creamer can create thick foam that can be used for intricate latte art!

These containers are sealed so tightly that you can store them in your pantry until you’re ready to open them! Don’t forget to put it in the fridge after you open it, though. The estimated time that it stays fresh after opening is about ten days.

A serving of this creamer is eight fluid ounces and has 130 calories, 7 grams of fat, and 14 grams of carbs. The numbers are higher than the rest on this list, but keep in mind that the serving size is much larger than the others!

One of the first ingredients is sunflower oil, which is known for being low in saturated fats and high in fatty acids. That means that the creamer will have more healthy fats for both you and your body!

All around, this seems like the ideal creamer for everyone, especially for those with allergies.

The only people who might not enjoy this creamer are those looking for a sweeter creamer or a powder creamer. If you were looking for the healthiest creamer for coffee, or just healthy coffee creamer options, this is the coffee creamer for you!

Coffee Creamer Buyers Guide

How do I choose the right coffee creamer?

When it comes to choosing the right coffee creamer, remember that there are no wrong choices to be made.

Every person is unique and has their taste and texture preferences. For example, you might love caramel flavored creamer, but your friend prefers French vanilla.

However let’s go over the different types of coffee creamers and which ones might be best for you!

Adding milk

If you don’t have time to run to the store, pouring some milk into your coffee can sweeten it up.

Common kinds of milk added to coffee include cow’s milk, goat’s milk, and buffalo milk Cow’s milk is commonly what is poured into coffee.

It can sweeten your coffee and add some thickness to the texture. However, keep in mind that the fat percentage and freshness of the milk can affect the outcome!

vanilla creamers

Goats Milk

Goats milk has become quite popular in the past few years as an additive to coffee. The milk will give your coffee an earthy taste and is also better for your body.

All milk taken from animals has a natural milk sugar called lactose in them. Though we humans start our lives by relying solely on milk, we begin to lose our tolerance for it as we grow older.

Goats milk is known to have less lactose than milk, making it a popular option for stomachs that might be more sensitive to lactose.

Recent research has also suggested that the consumption of goat’s milk could help enhance your ability to absorb other nutrients!

Buffalo Milk

Buffalo milk is also a good option to enhance your cup of coffee. Buffalo’s milk is creamier than most kinds of milk, so it will thicken up your coffee to give it a smooth texture.

When it comes to nutrition, buffalo milk has more protein and fat than cow’s milk. Protein can increase your stomach s feelings of fullness, so adding buffalo milk to your coffee will help you feel fuller for longer.

On the downside, buffalo’s milk has more lactose than regular milk. If you’re lactose intolerant or lactose sensitive, it might be best to stay away from buffalo milk.

Adding cream

Not to be confused with creamer, the cream is a dairy liquid with a higher fat content that can be added to your milk. If you’re trying to watch how much fat you consume, it might be best to avoid using cream in your coffee.

The main difference between cream and creamer is that cream is a dairy-based product used to sweeten and thicken coffee, while creamer is commonly dairy-free and uses other ingredients to replicate the same thickness you get from adding cream.

The most commonly added creams are half and half, light cream, light whipping cream, and heavy cream. Half-and-half gets its name from being made up of 50% milk and 50% cream.

Half and half is one of the most popular additives for coffee drinkers, as it adds thickness that milk can’t provide while also having the least amount of fat compared to other creams.

Light Cream

Light cream has more fat than half and half, containing 20% fat compared to half and half’s 12%. The higher the amount of fat, the thicker and sweeter your coffee becomes.

However, do keep in mind that creams with a higher fat content will add extra calories to your coffee, so it might be best to stick with something lower in fat if you’re trying to watch your calorie intake.

Light whipping cream has 30% fat compared to light cream’s 20%, meaning that light whipping cream will be slightly thicker and sweeter than light cream.

Heavy cream has the highest amount of fat compared to other creams. It’s the heaviest cream you can go with and can contain about 38% fat.

This cream will also add the most thickness to your cup of joe, as well as the most calories. It is recommended to be careful with how much of this cream you pour because too much of it will render the coffee too thick to enjoy.


Now that we’ve discussed all of the dairy products you can add to your coffee let’s talk about the main thing featured in this article. Creamers!

Creamers are a great choice for those who are lactose intolerant since the majority of creamers contain no dairy products at all. A nice level of thickness and sweetness can still be achieved with this non-dairy option.

Creamer thickens and sweetens your coffee just like creams made from dairy, but how? Well, creamers are made out of a combination of sugar water and vegetable oil.

Compared to dairy cream, conventional creamers can add more sugar and fat to your coffee.

Coffee creamer comes in two forms: liquid and powder. Each provides the same results and is only different in the way that you store them.

Liquid coffee creamers need to be stored in a refrigerator and will remain good for about two weeks after opening. Powder creamers are stored in a cool and dry place, such as a pantry.

They also have a longer shelf life than liquids and will still be useable up to six months after being opened.

One great thing about creamer is the sheer amount of available flavors. Flavors can range anywhere from simple French vanilla to whacky flavors like Cinnamon Toast Crunch.

The variety of flavors gives you the option to completely customize the coffee to your personal preferences.

Is coffee creamer bad for me?

Sadly when you add a large amount of creamer to your coffee every day, it can affect your health. If used in moderation, coffee creamer won’t negatively impact your health.

Too much of anything can be bad for you. and coffee creamer is no exception. The main danger lies within its added sugars and fats that can increase the amount of bad cholesterol in your body.

Never fear; there are healthier alternatives out there so that you don’t have to give up a sweeter and thicker cup of coffee. If you’re looking for a healthier option, keep an eye out for creamers that are fat-free and free of added sugars.

If possible, use traditional milk or plant-based milk because they are the healthiest option to add to your coffee.


So there you have it! Five highly rated coffee creamers that range in style, flavor, and price.

While coffee creamer can negatively affect your health, there are multiple options available that reduce the number of calories and sugars added to your coffee.

We discussed the various types of creamers available as well as their pros and cons.

There are dairy creamers like traditional dairy milk and cream, and there are also non-dairy options like coconut milk and oat milk that give you the same result without the lactose.

There are even creamers out there for people who enjoy adding a little more flavor to their coffee

Now that you know what you’re looking for in a coffee creamer, it’ll be easier for you to pick out one that works for you and your preferences.
Everybody has their preferences, so don’t be discouraged if you’re not a fan of a popular creamer!

Just keep searching, and you’ll find it!

That concludes this article about coffee creamers and the best that are available on the market today.

Thank you so much for taking the time to sit down and read, and we hope that you found the information that you were looking for!

Have a wonderful day, and don’t forget to be as sweet as a coffee creamer to those around you!

Avatar photo
About Denise Opi

Hi, my name is Denise and I hail from Lille, France. I am a teacher by day, and a coffee lover by night! My family owns a coffee farm, and I am excited to share my journey with everyone!